Once again, Phyllis has betrayed Jack by having an affair on The Young and the Restless. (Years ago, it was with Nick Newman.)

Only this time it’s worse! She’s been dancing in the sheets with Jack’s very own brother, Billy. While the doomed tryst is over — Phyllis has come to her senses and realizes she loves and belongs with Jack – her hurt husband doesn’t seem willing to forgive, forget, or reconcile. Soap Hub asked if Phyllis will ever find redemption.

Totally Unforgivable
Cheating on your husband is one thing, but cheating on him with his brother is downright deplorable. Of the over 6,500 fans that weighed in, 71% believe there’s no way Phyllis (Gina Tognoni) can find redemption from this.

The minute she crawled into bed with Billy (Jason Thompson), she crossed a major line. And it’s a line she can’t cross back over, no matter how much she wants to or how hard she tries. Jack (Peter Bergman) is crushed, humiliated, and totally justified when he says he can’t forgive her.

Making Amends
Phyllis isn’t the first one in Genoa City to have a scandalous affair, and she definitely won’t be the last. In time, 23% of you think she will find redemption and that Jack will take his philandering wife back. Yes, it will take a while – and lots and lots of counselling. Yet, you believe the two belong together, so they’ll overcome.

Too Messed Up to Call
Some 6% of you are in the same state of shock that Jack is and can’t make a call quite yet. You see Phyllis and Billy’s affair as a train wreck. Now that it’s over, the dust has to settle and the debris has to be cleared. Once that’s done, the track to love will be open again for Phyllis and Jack… Or maybe not.