Home > The Young and the Restless > Young and the Restless Commentary

Why Did Matt Reject Patty, Then Take the Same Deal From Phyllis on Y&R?

Matt thinks he’s making a moral choice, but he fails to see that both Patty and Phyllis are weaponizing his need for redemption.

Young and the Restless Matt ClarkPhoto Credit: JPI Studios

The Young and the Restless exposed a blind spot in Matt’s desperate attempt for a clean slate. He was quick to reject Patty when she tried to weaponize his craving for a new reputation. However, he missed how effectively Phyllis was playing the same card. He thought he broke free from a dark influence, but he walked into a similar version of the deal he just turned down. This dynamic forced Matt to navigate a dizzying array of promises, in which his desire to do good might just lead him back into more trouble.

Key Takeaways

Patty’s Manipulation and Phyllis’s Trap

Patty (Stacy Haiduk) was transparent about her desires on Monday’s episode. She wants Matt (Roger Howarth) to help tie up some “loose ends.” That basically meant she’s up to no good again.

She framed their partnership as his road to redemption. Matt could smell the danger from a mile away and shut her down immediately. He believed he was making a noble and moral choice. Yet, when Phyllis (Michelle Stafford) stepped in, she suggested they team up to trap Patty and emerge as Genoa City’s heroes.

These women’s two intentions are different. Phyllis doesn’t want Matt to go back on that dangerous road again, while Patty wants to use him to her advantage. She believed that he’s still the monster he always was.

Despite their different motives, the approach is similar. Both women are tying Matt’s redemption to the execution of a reckless scheme.

Matt’s Blind Spot With Two Master Motivators

Ultimately, Matt wasn’t choosing between a good influence and a bad influence. He was choosing between two women who knew his psychological desire.

Both Patty and Phyllis know that the easiest way to motivate Matt is to promise he can finally prove he’s changed. Phyllis packaged her scheme as a noble act, which blinds Matt to the fact that he’s still being manipulated into running a con.

He’s vulnerable to anyone who holds out the promise of a fresh start. He doesn’t realize they’re exposing him to the same old patterns of behavior.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.