Commentary Y&R

Where Were Sharon Newman’s Y&R Flashbacks?

Published by
Alina Adams

The Young and the Restless produced an entire episode devoted to Sharon Newman’s dream, where she wondered what she wanted out of life, both professionally and personally. Tessa sang, Billy summarized the drama Sharon has been through since she popped up as Nick’s high school girlfriend in 1994, and then she and Nick reenacted the aborted wedding where she and Billy learned that Nick and Phyllis had slept together — complete with a laugh track.

Sharon Newman Looks Back…But Not Really

It was very postmodern and existential. As was the entire episode. (Read our recap here.) We always cheer the writers trying something new, whether or not they manage to pull it off. But, nonetheless, one thing was still missing from this “special” episode.

The Way We Were

Where, we have to ask, were the flashbacks? Why reunite this wedding disaster, when we could have just…seen it? Yes, we know Phyllis was a different person then, as was little Faith. But we’re soap fans, we can accept a Gina Tognoni versus Michelle Stafford switch-a-roo, and the same goes for Alyvia Allyn Lind versus Reylynne Castor. Why ignore the real drama in favor of a campy imitation?

Show Not Tell

Was Billy (Jason Thompson) reminding Sharon (Sharon Case) of losing Cassie (Camryn Grimes), her on-again, off-again relationship with Nick (Joshua Morrow), or Adam (Mark Grossman) dismissing both her marriages to Rey (Jordi Vilasuso) and the flings with him as unimportant, really better than seeing snippets from those moments? We found it strange.

Compare and Contrast

Nikki (Melody Thomas Scott) got flashbacks for her special episode — even though she was in jail! We even saw some flashbacks during the big Claire reveal, where, for the record, Victoria (Amelia Heinle) was played by Heather Tom (Katie; The Bold and the Beautiful), and the effect wasn’t ruined. Why didn’t Sharon deserve the same treatment? We wanted that walk down Memory Lane!

The Young and the Restless airs weekdays on CBS. For an in-depth look at the show’s history, click here.

The best place for true soap fans to be is our Facebook groups. Have you joined? If you love soap spoilers, gossip, and fans as dedicated as yourself, check out Days of our Lives Fans, General Hospital Exclusive, The Young and the Restless Fans, and The Bold and the Beautiful Fans.

Load more...
Share
Published by
Alina Adams

Recent Posts

  • General Hospital Spoilers

General Hospital Spoilers November 25: The Trial of the Year Pits Ava Versus Kristina

On the next GH, Ava's trial begins and Kristina takes the stand. Also, Curtis opens… Read More

4 hours ago
  • General Hospital Spoilers

Weekly General Hospital Spoilers November 25-29: Taking Down Ava And Drew

The big day has arrived for both Ava and Lulu. Read More

4 hours ago
  • News

Why Kelly Ripa Wants Mark Consuelos To Be More Like Ryan Seacrest

Kelly Ripa encouraged Mark Consuelos to go "full Seacrest." Read More

5 hours ago
  • News

Here’s What to Expect from Hallmark’s Holiday Sequel “Three Wiser Men and a Boy”

Three Wiser Men and a Boy is a sequel to Hallmark's massive hit movie Three… Read More

5 hours ago
  • News & Rumors

Danny And Scout’s Living Arrangements Are Made On November 22 General Hospital… For Now

Not everyone will be happy over this decision. Read More

5 hours ago
  • News

Why Doctor Odyssey’s Pregnancy Storyline Might Be Short-Lived

Doctor Odyssey teased a pregnancy storyline in the fall finale. But fans might not even… Read More

6 hours ago