I Can’t Take It Anymore! Which Woman Will Crack First on The Young and the Restless (YR)?

Nikki may have been the one to crack JT’s skull on The Young and the Restless (YR), but Victoria, Sharon, and Phyllis all joined in burying him in the park bearing Kay’s name.

Now the four women harbor a secret… but as the saying goes, two people can keep a secret if one is dead. So, what does that mean for four co-conspirators?

If one goes down, so do the other three. So, which one will crack first? Almost 10,000 viewers played Columbo:

Sharon Can’t Help Sharin’
No question, 51% of you decree. It’ll be Sharon (Sharon Case). Remember how eager she was to spill about Christian’s paternity? The woman cannot keep a secret, especially where Nick (Joshua Morrow) is concerned.

Phyllis already warned Sharon about what will happen if she does, but if Chelsea smacking Sharon over the head with sticks and stones couldn’t stop her, what can Phyllis’ words do?

Will Victoria Waver?
Victoria (Amelia Heinle) could barely keep it together when Paul (Doug Davidson) questioned her, and she wanted to go to Victor (Eric Braeden) for help. That’s why 33% of the audience is certain she’ll be the weakest link.

Never Nikki
Only 11% think Nikki (Melody Thomas Scott) will be the one. Nikki has kept mum about other murders she’s committed (so, OK, so she repressed the memories), which means she has experience in the field. She’ll keep her mouth shut… unless alcohol is involved….

Phyllis Perhaps?
Not Phyllis (Gina Tognoni)! An even smaller percentage, a puny 5%, thinks she’ll be the one to confess all. Phyllis is too busy running around ordering Victoria and Sharon to keep it together – or else.

We have to wonder what Phyllis might do if Mariah (Camryn Grimes) ever remembers what she heard through the margarita-infused fog. If Mariah decides to reveal what she knows, we may be back to skull cracking…

The Young and the Restless (YR) airs weekdays on CBS. Check your local listings for airtimes.