The Baywatch rumor originated from Season 2, Episode 2 of The Valley. Jesse Lally spoke to Scheana Shay about his new girlfriend, Lacy Nicole. There was a rumor that she cheated on him with multiple men, including “the guy from Baywatch.” Nicole Eggert, who starred on the original series, shared her thoughts on this mystery.
Who’s The Guy From Baywatch?
Jesse met with his ex-wife, Michelle. The two had a tense discussion about co-parenting. Somehow, the conversation shifted to Michelle accusing Jesse’s new girlfriend of talking about him behind his back. She then revealed a claim that Lacy told Scheana that she had cheated on Jesse more than once.
Jesse immediately called up Scheana on the phone, who confirmed the rumor. She wouldn’t name who “the guy from Baywatch is.” However, this had fans wondering who the guy could be. Social media immediately burned up with questions like, “Who is the guy from Baywatch?” Most assumed they meant David Hasselhoff or Jeremy Jackson.
MORE: See how The Valley is like a soap opera.
Nicole Eggert Speaks Out
Now, the signs are pointing to David Charvet, an actor and singer who played Matt Brody from Seasons 3 to 6. Fans noticed that Lacy follows David on social media. Baywatch alum Nicole Eggert also seemingly cracked the case. She played Summer Quinn on the series. She shared her theory on the Monday, April 28 episode of the Perfectly Twisted podcast.
“I’m watching the show and they keep saying, ‘the guy from Baywatch’ and I’m thinking, ‘They’re going to show who it is’— and they don’t,” Nicole said, noting her disappointment. “My mind starts to race because I’m very close to Jeremy Jackson, who I know is not watching Bravo. He’s not watching TV, and he lives in Orange County, and his girlfriend lives in Orange County.”
Nicole called Jeremy and explained the rumor to him. The two laughed about it. Nicole concluded that “the guy from Baywatch” is someone else. “It was a big relief. I really kind of narrowed it down to David Charvet. To me, it’s the only one that it could be,” she concluded.
This is just Nicole’s assumption. She didn’t want to make any declarations. “It would be David Charvet because he’s single and dates a lot and is a free, single guy.” Who do you think “the guy from Baywatch” is? Let us know in the comments section.
