Three’s a Crowd: Who Is the Right Man For Phyllis on The Young and the Restless?

Phyllis has a pretty full dance card on The Young and the Restless these days. She’s living with Nick (Joshua Morrow)… again.

But Billy (Jason Thompson) is both playing her at work and pining for her during his off hours. Plus, there’s Jack (Peter Bergman). He never quite got over his wife’s affair with his brother, and there are unresolved feelings there on both sides.

So who is the right man for Phyllis (Gina Tognoni)? What almost 6,000 fans had to say!

Jack Should Be Back
Nick cheated on Phyllis. Billy lied to her about gambling again. Jack’s big crime during their marriage was being kidnapped by Victor (Eric Braeden), replaced by a lookalike who slept with Phyllis… and Jack had to suffer the consequences.

For 59% of you, this is the best reason for Phyllis to return to her ex-husband. Unlike Billy and Nick, he’s a grown up.

My Boy Bill
Billy broke up with Phyllis because she slept with Nick. But they were on a BREAK! Billy had moved out.

Phyllis was a single woman. Sure, maybe she should have told him about it after they reunited. But, Billy would have only huffed and puffed. And nobody wants to see that. As a result, 35% of the audience sees unfinished business with this pair. Billy is hanging around Phyllis quite a bit…and it’s not only because of Jabot.

Nick Trick
Only 6% want to watch a Nick and Phyllis rerun. They were hot the first time around. But then Summer (Hunter King) was the result. Does anyone think Summer is a good result to anything?

Nick and Phyllis always try to make it work, and then Nick and Phyllis always fail to make it work. Put a fork in it, this turkey is done.

The Young and the Restless (YR) airs weekdays on CBS. Check your local listings for airtimes.