The Usual Suspects: Who Will Be Arrested First On The Young and the Restless?

On The Young and the Restless, Rey is itching to make an arrest. He doesn’t care who it will be at this point, he just needs something he can show his superiors so he can stay in Genoa City.

Nikki (Melody Thomas Scott), Victoria (Amelia Heinle), Phyllis (Gina Tognoni), and Sharon (Sharon Case) all bear varying amounts of guilt for what happened the night JT (Thad Luckinbill) disappeared. Who will be arrested first? Over 10,000 think you know!

It’s a Tie!
Nikki is the one who smacked JT over the head with a fire poker. But Victoria is who he was attacking. So they are both key players. Which is probably why 30% of you have put your money on Nikki… and an equal 30% put it on Victoria.

They both have means, motive, and opportunity. Plus, they’re the ones Rey (Jordi Vilasuso) had his eye on in the first place. They’re rich, they’re high-profile and, oh, yeah, they’re actually guilty. Book ’em, Rey-O!

Tiny Difference
Only a smidge less, 29%, think it will be Sharon. Think about it, she’s the one most actively breaking the law, sneaking peeks at Rey’s files.

What’s he supposed to think but that Sharon is responsible? Not to mention, now that his wife, Mia (Noemi Gonzalez), is back in town, Rey needs an excuse to spend time with Sharon. If he has to put handcuffs on her to make it happen, so be it!

Crazy Like a Ph(ox)
One thing 10% of the audience knows about Phyllis, she always lands on her feet. She may have been the one who suggested wrapping JT in a rug and dumping him six feet under, but she is also the one who knows how to get out of trouble best.

Phyllis is going to be the last person Rey goes after. She’ll make damn sure of that!

The Young and the Restless (YR) airs weekdays on CBS. Check your local listings for airtimes.