Paul Calafiore Says “S&M” Was Dealbreaker With Danielle Maltby

Former Bachelor star Danielle Maltby recently aired some dirty laundry about her ex-boyfriend’s cheating past, and now he’s trying to do damage control.

Paul Calafiore, who has been on both Big Brother and The Challenge, allegedly cheated on Danielle with his Challenge co-star Cara Maria Sorbello.

Danielle took to Instagram earlier this week to share her thoughts on the whole ordeal, claiming Paul had been playing both Danielle and Cara.

It didn’t take long for Paul to take to Instagram himself to explain his side of the story.

In the video he says that he was in love with Danielle when he went to film The Challenge, but developed a strong connection with Cara.

In an unexpected twist, he also claimed he couldn’t go back to Danielle because she’s not into “S&M.”

“I knew that things weren’t ever going to work with Danielle and I because she wasn’t into any of that stuff,” he said.

“Danielle only wanted to make love.”

In fact, he even said he had sex with Cara while she was wearing Danielle’s lingerie, which is certainly strange.

“I couldn’t be with somebody that isn’t into S&M,” he continued.

Paul also believes Danielle is coming out with her story now because he has moved on with Cara.

“Danielle specifically waited until I was in Disney with Cara after I told her I didn’t want to be with anybody else but Cara,” he said.

“That’s when she decides to come out with all these articles.”

He continued, “Danielle, I’m sorry for what I did to you… I didn’t know how to handle this situation… I couldn’t stop loving you. I’m sorry. I couldn’t stop this… I told you in Mexico that this wasn’t going to work.”

This is all such a mess! Are you Team Danielle or Team Paul?

[gravityform id=”12″ title=”true” description=”true”]