Home > Days of our Lives > Days of our Lives News

Exclusive Preview: Jen Lilley Reveals What Really Happened With Her Days of our Lives Exit

Jen Lilley says there was no feud over her Days of our Lives recasting, but she didn’t know she was being replaced. Here’s what happened.

Days of our Lives Jen Lilley.Photo Credit: JPI Studios

Former Days of our Lives star Jen Lilley is revealing exactly how her return as Theresa Donovan ended with Emily O’Brien taking over the role, and she says she never knew she was being replaced. In an exclusive clip shared with SoapHub ahead of her appearance on the We’re Out of Time podcast, Lilley explained how a brief return to honor the late John Aniston turned into an unexpected recasting that she says “was not handled well.”

Key Takeaways

  • Jen Lilley revealed she didn’t know Days of our Lives planned to replace her as Theresa Donovan.
  • Her proposed brief return for John Aniston’s tribute became a much longer storyline.
  • Lilley said there are no hard feelings toward Emily O’Brien, despite how the situation unfolded.

A Simple Offer Turned Into Something Bigger

Lilley originally reached out to DAYS following the death of John Aniston, who played Victor Kiriakis. She thought that Theresa’s brief return to Salem would be a fitting way to honor the late actor.

“I had made the mistake of emailing them,” Lilley told host Richard Taite. She explained that she’d suggested Theresa could return for a few episodes, shake things up, and leave. However, the show’s writers apparently had something much bigger in mind.

According to Lilley, the show wrote Theresa back into the story without first confirming her availability for an extended run. With five children and other commitments, the actress couldn’t accommodate a full-time return.

How Emily O’Brien Ended Up Playing Theresa

The production reportedly offered Lilley a compromise. Instead of filming 12 weeks of episodes as part of the usual schedule, they would condense her work into 4 weeks. Lilley agreed, but things took another unexpected turn. After just two weeks, the show decided to bring in O’Brien to finish Theresa’s storyline.

“I didn’t know I was being replaced,” Lilley revealed. She described the decision as a major surprise and acknowledged that the situation wasn’t handled particularly well.

What’s interesting is that Lilley doesn’t appear to blame O’Brien for what happened. In fact, she made it clear that the recasting itself wasn’t the problem.

No Feud, but Plenty of Questions

Soap fans may remember the surprise surrounding O’Brien’s transition into Theresa, especially since the actress had previously portrayed Gwen Rizczech. However, Lilley’s explanation suggests the behind-the-scenes situation was more complicated than viewers realized.

Lilley emphasized that there was no personal feud. She wasn’t in a position to commit to the demanding schedule of a daytime soap, and the production ultimately made another choice.

Still, her account raises an interesting question about how the situation was communicated. Lilley agreed to an accelerated filming schedule, only to learn that her return would end earlier than expected.

Fans can hear more when Lilley’s full interview on We’re Out of Time premieres Tuesday, November 17, at noon PT on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts, and other podcast platforms.


Hosted by Richard Taite, founder and chairman of Carrara Treatment Wellness & Spa and chairman of 1 Method Centers. Available Tuesday, Nov. 17 at 12 p.m. PT on YouTube, Spotify, Apple Podcasts and wherever you get your podcasts.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.