In the November 20 episode of The Young and the Restless, Nick’s mysterious meeting in an alley suggested that his secret involving Matt might be far more complicated than Sharon and Phyllis realize. While both women have been trying to uncover what Nick did to Matt, they may be asking the wrong question. The bigger concern might be what Nick is still doing.
Nick Uses His Sobriety to Shut Down Questions
Sharon (Sharon Case, who will have a different role) and Nick (Joshua Morrow) appeared to make some progress when she admitted she’d told Nikki (Melody Thomas Scott) about the fentanyl pills. Although Nick wasn’t happy about it, he understood that Sharon was concerned about his recovery.
However, when Sharon asked whether he was ready to tell her and Phyllis (Michelle Stafford) what happened to Matt (Roger Howarth), Nick refused. He argued that constantly discussing Matt wasn’t helping him maintain his sobriety.
That puts Sharon in an incredibly difficult position. She believes Nick’s secrecy threatens his recovery, while he suggests that her efforts to uncover the truth could do the same. Whether Nick intended it or not, he made Sharon feel that pursuing answers could hurt someone she’s desperately trying to help.
Phyllis Finds Another Reason to Distrust Nick
While Nick and Sharon talked, Phyllis noticed several missed calls on Nick’s phone from a contact identified only as WM. When she questioned him about it, Nick dismissed the calls as business-related before leaving.

Phyllis wasn’t convinced, and she suspected the caller had something to do with Matt. Sharon shared her concerns, prompting the two women to commit to uncovering the mysterious caller’s identity.
What makes their alliance particularly significant is that neither woman appears interested in competing for Nick’s affection. Their shared concern about his behavior has become more important than their longstanding rivalry. Unfortunately, Nick’s subsequent actions suggested they have good reason to worry.
Nick’s Secret May Be an Ongoing Arrangement
Nick met a mysterious man in an alley who told him he had news about their patient. Although the patient’s identity wasn’t confirmed, the encounter raised disturbing questions about Nick’s involvement in Matt’s disappearance.

Until now, Sharon and Phyllis have largely focused on discovering what Nick did to Matt. The possibility that Nick has an ongoing arrangement with someone makes the situation considerably more troubling.
It also puts Victor’s (Eric Braeden) recent reaction to learning Nick’s secret in a different light. Victor appeared impressed by whatever Nick revealed, which hardly seems reassuring given Victor’s history of dealing with his enemies.
Nick wants Sharon and Phyllis to stop focusing on Matt, yet his secret meeting suggests he may not have moved on himself. If he’s continuing to involve himself in Matt’s fate while trying to maintain his sobriety, the consequences could extend well beyond whatever revenge he originally sought.
Sharon and Phyllis thought they were trying to uncover Nick’s past actions. They may discover that the most disturbing part of his secret is that it isn’t over.
