Home > General Hospital > General Hospital Commentary

Was Sidwell’s Beating A Setup On General Hospital?

Sonny may or may not have ordered the hit. Who else could have?

General Hospital's SidwellImage Credit: ABC Media

General Hospital‘s Sidwell was badly beaten in Pentonville. The evidence points to Sonny, but he may not be the culprit. If not him, then who?

Key Takeaways

  • Sidwell and Curtis were beaten in Pentonville, and it looks like Sonny ordered the hit.
  • Sonny may be innocent.
  • Sidwell may have planned his own attack.
  • Drew could be the guilty party.

Did Sonny Do It?

There is an intense dislike between Sonny (Maurice Benard) and Sidwell (Carlo Rota), and their rivalry didn’t end when Jenz was sent to Pentonville. Sonny seemed suspicious when he went to the prison to meet with an old mob associate and asked him to pass a message to some inmates.

Sidwell seemed to know that an attack was imminent. He offered to pay Curtis (Donnell Turner) to protect him, but his cellmate declined. He then confronted Alexis (Nancy Lee Grahn) in the visitor’s room and begged her to do something to save him. She also declined his request.

Curtis was warned to stay out of his cell, and then a bunch of inmates beat Sidwell so badly that Curtis intervened. That was when they hit Curtis as well. Before the group ran off, one of them claimed that the order came from Sonny.

A Drew Or Sidwell Setup

All roads point to Sonny, but that may be too obvious. Sonny is ruthless, but he is intent on leaving his mob days behind him. Sidwell is already behind bars, so there is not much reason to have him beaten to death. Also, he would have made sure that Curtis was not hurt.

One theory is that Sidwell set the whole thing up to accuse Sonny. Sonny goes to prison, where Sidwell can even the score. This is why he put the idea in both Alexis and Curtis heads beforehand.

Jenz may be a little crazy, but he wouldn’t have had anyone beat him as badly as they did. He could have died, and he would not have let it get that far.

Drew (Cameron Mathison) may also be the culprit. He and Ava (Maura West) have been plotting against Sonny for quite some time, and this is the perfect setup. If they had Sidwell beaten up and Sonny take the blame, it would kill two birds with one stone. Drew’s vendetta would be complete.

Who do you think did it?

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.