Before there was Andrew DeLuca (Giacomo Gianniotti) and Meredith Grey’s (Ellen Pompeo) relationship on Grey’s Anatomy, there was DeLuca and Meredith’s half sister Maggie Pierce’s (Kelly McCreary) romance.
In this awkward flashback video, DeLuca and Maggie address the fact they hooked up the night before, while also vowing to not let it happen again. Something Grey’s Anatomy viewers have obviously never seen before (cough cough).
“I was coming to apologize to you. That yelling was not about today. It was about last night,” Maggie says. “Last night is not going to happen again. It was very nice — it was better than nice — but I don’t do this.” Watch the clip above to hear DeLuca’s response, as well as see what happened next between the pair!