Home > Entertainment

10 Bachelor Alums Who Should Go On Bachelor in Paradise


We are just weeks away from the premiere episode of Hannah B’s season of The Bachelorette, but some fans are already thinking about Bachelor in Paradise.

Though we’re a few months away from that show’s premiere, we can’t help but wonder who will be hitting that Mexico beach this summer. From recent Bachelor alums to some of our favorites from the past, here are 10 former The Bachelor stars who should go on this season of Bachelor in Paradise!

1. Olivia Caridi
We know she swore off Bachelor spinoffs after her horrible experience on Ben Higgins’ season of The Bachelor, but she’d be an awesome contestant. Not only is she ready for a relationship, she has her priorities in check.

2. Blake Horstmann
There’s no way Blake Horstmann isn’t going on Paradise. After finishing as the runner-up on Becca Kufrin’s season of The Bachelorette, all Blake wants is to find love!

3. Hannah Godwin
Despite being forgotten on Colton Underwood’s season, Hannah left the show as a fan-favorite. Not to mention, countless viewers are shipping her with Blake!

4. Caelynn Miller-Keyes
After sharing her devastating sexual assault story on The Bachelor, Caelynn has proven she’s an incredibly strong woman. We’d love to see her find a real connection on Paradise.

5. Derek Peth
Though Derek has already been on Paradise — and got engaged — it’d be fun to see him back on the show. He’s a good guy with a real job in New York City, which makes him a little more desirable than some of the other men who are “social media influencers.”

What do you think? Post a comment!

6. Shawn Booth
This will probably never happen, but how epic would it be if Shawn decided to join Paradise? It’s no secret he went through a devastating breakup with ex-fiancée Kaitlyn Bristowe last year, but she’s already moved on with Jason Tartick, so it’s time for Shawn to move on too!

7. Demi Burnett
Demi is almost certainly going to be on Paradise this year, which is fantastic because she knows how to bring the party. She may not find a lasting relationship, but she will be fun to watch!

8. Nick Viall
There’s probably a 1% chance Nick would ever do a Bachelor-related show again, but one can dream! Nick was definitely the voice of reason when he was on Bachelor in Paradise a few years ago and it would be nice to have him back again.

9. Tayshia Adams
After she stirred the pot during Colton Underwood’s season, we’d love to see Tayshia on Paradise. She’s not afraid to start some drama, which the show always could use.

10. Jordan Kimball
Despite going through a rough breakup after his time on Paradise last season, we need to see Jordan back on our television screens. Like Demi, he always knows how to be entertaining!

Do you agree with our picks? Let us know what you think in the comments section below.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.

Subscribe Now

Get spoilers, news and recaps in your inbox daily.