Daytime history was made when The Young and the Restless character Sheila Carter moved from outside of Genoa City, where she was presumed dead in a cabin fire, to Los Angeles home of The Bold and the Beautiful. She’s returned to both shows many times over the years.
Sheila was presumed dead after longtime nemesis Lauren (Tracey Bregman) shot Sheila (when she was played by Michelle Stafford, currently Nina on General Hospital, soon to be Phyllis once again on YR).
JOIN SOAPHUB INSIDER: Get Monthly Fireside Chats With Popular Soap Stars
Sheila was woven back onto the canvas amidst controversy. Eric was willing to give Sheila another chance while Quinn was not, resulting in some knockdown drag-outs between the two women that destroyed many a Forrester mansion vase!
After a while, Sheila got a job at a local eatery Il Giardino as a server where she presumably still works even though she hasn’t been seen in a while.
Is it time for Sheila to return? The majority of you, nearly 82%, say no. You’re okay with Sheila not coming back. Perhaps you feel her story has run out on BB. Or maybe you’d like to see her go back to YR instead.
There’s a current baby mystery going on right now on BB with baby Beth really being baby Phoebe. Wouldn’t it be a great twist if once the truth comes out, the baby goes missing courtesy of Sheila?
The rest of you, a little over 18%, say yes, you’d like to see Sheila return. In addition to the previously mentioned baby storyline, Sheila could be worked into the show in other ways.
Her rivalry with Quinn could be re-activated. And there’s also a big mystery as to how Sheila is alive when we saw her die on YR? If Sheila didn’t die, then who did?
The Bold and the Beautiful airs weekdays on CBS. Check local listings for airtimes.